The Characterization of ISIL Under International Law and Islamic Sharia

Ayad Yasin Husein Kokha

doi:10.21271/zjhs.27.6.15

المؤلفون

Ayad Yasin Husein Kokha College of Law,Salahaddin University–Erbil Junior Thyssen Fellow at the Institute for Advanced Study: Central European University (IAS CEU). I acknowledge the sponsorship of the IAS Fellowship and the financial assistance of IAS CEU and CEU Budapest Foundation for this article received between October 1st, 2021, and June 30th, 2022.

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.21271/zjhs.27.6.15

الكلمات المفتاحية:

ISIL Characterization، International Law، Sharia

الملخص

A curious phenomenon has appeared on the contemporary international scene: The Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant (ISIL). They seized vast areas of Iraq between 2014 and 2017 and committed appalling crimes against innocent civilians in the areas they controlled. They targeted certain minorities with particular viciousness, persecuting them in the name of religion in contravention of both humanitarian principles and the religious precepts of Islam. This paper attempts to characterize the nature of ISIL in the form they took during their armed conflict against the Iraqi and Kurdistani regular armed forces and against the anti-ISIL international coalition forces. This characterization will be done through the lenses of both international law and Sharia. ISIL misinterpreted certain Quranic verses by neglecting traditional rules of interpretation for the Quran and Sharia in order to legitimize their extremist ideology and horrible actions. This understandably contributed to an increase in Islamophobia in non-Muslim nations. Methodologically, this paper’s analysis draws upon the foundational texts and views of scholars of both international and Sharia law. It concludes that ISIL is neither a state under international law nor is it Islamic according to the Sharia. By carefully classifying the nature and essence of ISIL as an organization and by clarifying certain ambiguities concerning their legal status under both international law and Sharia, this article aims to help legal and religious scholars improve their conceptual clarity on the matter, and thereby also improve the consistency and precision of their rulings and provisions going forward.

المراجع

-The Holy Quran.

-Abdul-Hakim, M. (2015) The Giant of the Last of Age Sufyani ISIL... and the Black Banners of the End of Times [in Arabic]. Damascus: Dar Al-Kitab Al-Arabi.

-Abou-El-Wafa, A. (2010) The Mediator in the Public International Law [in Arabic]. 5th ed. Cairo: Dar Al-Nahda Al-Arabia.

-Ahmed, F. (2021) ISIS’s Interpretation of the Holy Quran: A study for the main cover line of the first and second issue of the Dabiq magazine, ZANCO Journal of Humanity Sciences, 25(2).

-Akoum, F. (2015) ISIL: The Black Book [in Arabic]. Cairo: Dar Amili.

-Al-Ashaal, A. (2015) ISIL Under International Law: Legal Analysis [in Arabic], [Online]. Available at: <https://www-aljazeera-net.translate.goog/news/humanrights/2015/2/11/تنظيم-داعش-في-نظر-القانون-الدولي?_x_tr_sl=ar&_x_tr_tl=en&_x_tr_hl=en&_x_tr_pto=sc> Accessed: 2 October 2022.

-Alvarez-Jimenez, A. (2017) From Al-Qaida in 2001 to ISIL in 2015: The Security Council’s Decisions on Terrorism and Their Impact on the Right to Self-Defense Against Autonomous Non-State Actors, Minnesota Journal of International Law, 26(2).

-Atwan, A. (2015) The Islamic State: Roots, Savagery and Future [in Arabic]. 3rd Ed. Beirut: Dar al-Saqi.

-Bassiouni M. Ch. (2002) Legal Control of International Terrorism: A PolicyOriented Assessment. Harvard International Law Journal, 43(1).

-Corten, O. (2016) L’«ÉTAT ISLAMIQUE», UN ÉTAT? ENJEUX ET AMBIGUÏTÉS D’UNE QUALIFICATION JURIDIQUE, in Daech et le droit [in French]. 1st Ed. Panthéon Assas.

-Crawford J. (2006) The Creation of States in International Law. 2nd ed. Oxford University Press.

-Dabiq magazine. All issues in PDF format at the Clarion Project (2014-2016), Islamic State’s (ISIS, ISIL) Horrific Magazine, [Online]. Available at: <https://clarionproject.org/2014/09/10/islamic-state-isis-isil-propaganda-magazine-dabiq-50/> Accessed: 30 December 2022.

-Dabiq magazine. Vol. 1 (July 5, 2014), at 26, available at Clarion Project, [Online]. Available at: <https://clarionproject.org/docs/isis-isil-islamic-state-magazine-Issue-1-the-return-of-khilafah.pdf> Accessed: 30 December 2022.

-Dabiq magazine. Vol. 2 (July 27, 2014), at 26, available at the Clarion Project Website: <https://clarionproject.org/docs/isis-isil-islamic-state-magazine-Issue-2-the-flood.pdf> Accessed: 30 December 2022.

-Federal Supreme Court (2021) Rulings and Resolutions of the Federal Supreme Court [in Arabic], Vol. 12, Baghdad: Dar Al-Iraqiya for printing, publishing and distribution, 2022.

-France 24 (2019) Trump announces death of IS group leader Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi, WEB NEWS, [Online]. Available at: <https://www.france24.com/en/20191027-live-trump-makes-major-statement-amid-reports-of-al-baghdadi-death> Accessed: 27 May 2022.

-Frissen, Th., Toguslub, E., Van Ostaeyenc, P. & d'Haenensa, L. (2018) Capitalizing on the Koran to fuel [Online]. Available at: violent radicalization. A taxonomy of Koranic references in ISIS’s Dabiq. Journal of Telematics and Informatics, 35(2).

-Gold Z. & Faber, P. (2017) Al-Qaeda in Iraq (AQI): An Al-Qaeda Affiliate Case Study. Washington: The Center for Naval Analyses.

-Hogeback, J. (2021) Is It ISIS or ISIL? Encyclopedia Britannica, Inc., [Online]. Available at: <https://www.britannica.com/story/is-it-isis-or-isil> Accessed: 21 April 2023.

-Human Rights Council (2014) Report of the Independent International Commission of Inquiry on the Syrian Arab Republic: Rule of Terror: Living under ISIS in Syria. Twenty-seventh session: Agenda item 4: Human rights situations that require the Council’s attention. UN Doc A/HRC/27/CRP.3, 19 November 2014, [Online]. Available at:<https://documents-dds-ny.un.org/doc/UNDOC/GEN/G14/223/56/PDF/G1422356.pdf?OpenElement> Accessed: 19 November 2022.

-Human Rights Watch (2018) World Report: Events of 2017, USA: Sept. 16, 2017, at 285, [Online]. Available at:<https://www.hrw.org/sites/default/files/world_report_download/201801world_report_web.pdf> Accessed: 26 May 2022.

-ICRC (2015) What are jus ad bellum and jus in bello? International Committee of the Red Cross, 22 January 2015, [Online]. Available at:<https://www.icrc.org/en/document/what-are-jus-ad-bellum-and-jus-bello-0> Accessed: 2 May 2023.

-Kanso, W. The Modern State: Characteristics and Functions [in Arabic], Konrad-Adenauer-Stiftung Jordan, [Online]. Available at: <https://www.kas.de/documents/279984/280033/The+Modern+State+Paper.pdf/8fde4e95-71eb-9078-5f04-d71e5a9a31c7?version=1.0&t=1629032607078>Accessed: 1 May 2023.

-Kaufman, J., Mustafa, Sh. & Littlefield, H. (2015) What Using The Name ‘Dae’sh, Rather Than ‘ISIS’ or ‘ISIL,’ Really Means. Northeastern University Publications, [Online]. Available at: <https://news.northeastern.edu/2015/11/24/3qs-what-using-the-name-daesh-rather-than-isis-or-isil-really-means/> Accessed: 5 March 2021.

-Kenny, C. (2017) Prosecuting Crimes of International Concern: Islamic State at the ICC?, Utrecht Journal of International and European Law 33(84).

-Kirovska, G. (2017) Prosecuting ISIS under International Criminal Law. BA Liberal Arts and Sciences-Major Law in Europe. Tilburg University.

-Kokha A. Y. H. (2019) The Extent to Which ISIL’s Acts Against Iraqi Minorities Amount to Genocide. Quebec Journal of International Law, 32(2).

-Kurdistan Parliament – Iraq (2021) The Iraqi Kurdistan Parliament is conducting the first reading of the draft law on the criminal court for ISIS crimes, and the second reading of the draft law of the Ministry of Electricity [in Arabic], [Online]. Available at:<https://www.parliament.krd/arabic-news/posts/2021/may/برلمان-كوردستان-يجري-القراءة-الأولى-لمشروع-قانون-المحكمة-الجنائية-الخاصة-بجرائم-داعش-والقراءة-الثانية-لمشروع-قانون-وزارة-الكهرباء/> Accessed: 2 May 2023.

-Lia B. (2015) Understanding Jihadi Proto-States, Perspectives on Terrorism: Terrorism Research Initiative: Leiden University, 9(4).

-Longobardo, M. (2017) The self-proclaimed statehood of the Islamic State between 2014 and 2017 and International Law, Anuario Español de Derecho Internacional, 33.

-Maarouf, M. (2017) ISIL Passed Through Here [in Kurdish]. Erbil: Jungle Press.

-Mahmood, Q. (2021) Mechanisms for the Prosecution of ISIL Members Accused of International Crimes [in Arabic]. Beirut: Zein Juridique Publications.

-Manna, H. (2015) The Caliphate of ISIL [in Arabic]. Beirut: Bissan for Publishing Distribution & Information.

-Montevideo Convention on the Rights and Duties of States (1933) The treaty was ratified by 19 Latin American states and the US, 165 I.N.T.S. 19.

-Mossallanejad, A. (2016) The Rise of ISIS and the Future of Iraq’s Security, Geopolitics Quarterly 11(4).

-Muir, J. (2016) The ‘Full Story’ of Islamic State [in Arabic], BBC News: Middle East, [Online]. Available at: <https://www.bbc.com/arabic/middleeast/2016/04/160427_islamic_state_group_full_story> Accessed: 15 October 2021.

-Novogrodsky, N. B. (2018) Is ISIS a State: The Status of Statehood in the Age of Terror. Berkeley Journal of International Law, 36(1).

-Pompeo, M. R. (2019) On the Death of Abu Bakr Al-Baghdadi. Press Statement: The U.S. Department of State, [Online]. Available at: <https://2017-2021.state.gov/on-the-death-of-abu-bakr-al-baghdadi/index.html> Accessed: 1 March 2023.

-Riedel, B. (2008) The Search for al-Qaeda. Washington: Brookings Institution Press.

-Salah, M. & Dirabroosh, H. (2021) Contemporary Jihadist Organizations and Reasons for their Emergence [in Arabic], ZANCO Journal of Humanity Sciences, 25(1).

-Salloum, S. (2017) Protection of Religious, Ethnic and Linguistic Minorities in Iraq: Analytical Study in International: Regional and National Frameworks [in Arabic]. Baghdad: Iraqi Al-Amal Association.

-Shandhab M. (2014) ISIL: Its Essence, Origin, Terrorism and Objectives [in Arabic]. Beirut – Lebanon: Arab Scientific Publishers, Inc.

-Tabeeb, A. & Tarbak, T. (2014) Media treatment of issues related to ISIL: An analytical descriptive study [in Arabic]. Master’s thesis. Larbi Ben M'hidi University of Oum El Bouaghi, Algeria.

-The Anti-Terrorism Law in the Iraqi Kurdistan Region (2006) No. 3 of 2006 [in Kurdish] (Presidency of Kurdistan Region, Erbil on July, 16, 2006) 61, Al-Waqai Al-Kurdistaniya (The official gazette which allocated to dissemination of laws in Iraqi Kurdistan).

-The Iraqi Anti-Terrorism Law (2005) No. 13 of 2005 [in Arabic]. (Publications of the Presidency Council of Iraq: Baghdad on November, 9, 2005) 4003, Al-Waqai Al-Iraqia (The official gazette which allocated to dissemination of laws in Iraq).

-The Rome Statute (1998) Adopted in Rome on 17 July 1998, came into effect on 1 July 2002, UN Secretary-General, Treaty Series, 2187(38544).

-The UN Charter (1945).

-The Imam al-Albani Center for Scientific Studies and Research (2014) Yesterday’s Kharijites-Dissidents... Today’s Takfiris: ISIL as a Model [In Arabic]. Publications of the Scientific Symposium held at the Imam al-Albani Center for Studies and Research Association in Jordan.

-Tomuschat, Ch. (2015) The Status of the 'Islamic State' under International Law. Berliner Wissenschafts-Verlag, 90(3/4).

-UNITAD (2018) Letter dated 15 November 2018 from the Special Adviser and Head of the UNITAD addressed to the President of the Security Council. S/2018/1031 UNSC, [Online]. Available at:<https://www.unitad.un.org/sites/www.unitad.un.org/files/general/16.11.2018.pdf> Accessed: 6 February 2022.

-United Nations Assistance Mission for Iraq (UNAMI) and Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights -OHCHR- (2020) Human Rights in the Administration of Justice in Iraq: Trials under the anti-terrorism laws and implications for justice, accountability and social cohesion in the aftermath of ISIL. Baghdad, Iraq, International Report: January 2020, [Online]. Available at:<https://www.ohchr.org/Documents/Countries/IQ/UNAMI_Report_HRAdministrationJustice_Iraq_28January2020.pdf> Accessed: 25 March 2021.

-UNSC Resolution S/RES/2170 (2014): adopted at its 7242nd meeting, 15 August 2014, [Online]. Available at:<https://undocs.org/S/RES/2170(2014)> Accessed: 29 April 2021.

-UNSC Resolution S/RES/2249 (2015): adopted by UNSC at its 7565th meeting, 20 November 2015, [Online]. Available at:<https://undocs.org/S/RES/2249(2015)> Accessed: 5 May 2022.

-UNSC Resolution S/RES/2379 (2017): adopted at its 8052nd meeting, 21 September 2017, [Online]. Available at:<https://documents-dds-ny.un.org/doc/UNDOC/GEN/N17/296/25/PDF/N1729625.pdf?OpenElement> Accessed: 31 September 2021.

-UNSC Resolutions [S/RES/2160 (2014); S/RES/2161 (2014); S/RES/2169 (2014); S/RES/2178 (2014); S/RES/2199 (2015) and S/RES/2249 (2015)]: UNSC/Documents, [Online]. Available at:<https://www.un.org/securitycouncil/content/resolutions-0#main-content> Accessed: 19 May 2022.

-Wallace, D., McCarthy, A. & Reeves’l, Sh. (2017) Trying to Make Sense of the Senseless: Classifying the Syrian War Under the Law of Armed Conflict, Michigan State International Law Review, 25(3).

-Walter, Ch. (2003) Defining Terrorism in National and International Law (Paper presented at the Max Planck Society Conference on Terrorism as a Challenge for National and International Law, 24 January 2003. Heidelberg, [Online]. Available at: <https://iusgentium.ufsc.br/wp-content/uploads/2017/03/1-2-Defining-Terrorism-in-National-and-International-Law-Christian-Walter.pdf> Accessed: 12 Nov. 2022.

-Waltman III, G. (2016) Prosecuting ISIS, University of Mississippi School of Law, [Online]. Available at: <https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2537044> Accessed: 21 November 2021.

-Warrick, J. (2015) Black flags: The rise of ISIS. New York: Doubleday.

-Word Finder (2021), [Online]. Available at: <https://findwords.info/term/proto-state> Accessed: 11 April 2021.

-Yassir Abdul-Mohsen, The Third World War: ISIL, Iraq, and Managing Savagery [in Arabic] (Beirut: Press Corporation of Distribution and Publishing, 2015).