Performance Evaluation of Conventional Water Treatment Plants Using Turbidity and Disinfection Parameters

Yaseen Ahmed Hamaamin

doi:10.21271/ZJPAS.38.1.14

Authors

Yaseen Ahmed Hamaamin Civil Engineering Department, College of Engineering, University of Sulaimani, Sulaymaniyah, KRG, Iraq https://orcid.org/0000-0003-2621-7489

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.21271/ZJPAS.38.1.14

Keywords:

Water Treatment Plant, Efficiency, Turbidity, Chlorine

Abstract

Conventional water treatment plants (WTPs) typically involve two primary processes: turbidity removal and disinfection. This study evaluates the turbidity removal efficiency and the effectiveness of chlorination using daily records collected over one year from two WTPs, Dokan-1 and Dokan-2, located in the Sulaymaniyah Governorate, Kurdistan Region of Iraq.

Results of the study indicate mean turbidity removal efficiencies of 23.8% for Dokan-1 and 37.4% for Dokan-2. Although these values appear low, the performance of both plants is considered acceptable, as the 95^th percentile of influent water turbidity during the study year was 9.46 NTU. The findings suggest that high turbidity removal efficiency is not expected when raw water turbidity is below 10 NTU. Therefore, assessing efficiency without considering influent turbidity is not a reliable approach. Throughout the study year of 2023, the average effluent turbidity values remained below the permissible limit of 5 NTU, with Dokan-1 and Dokan-2 recording averages of 3.27 NTU and 2.95 NTU, respectively. A one-sample t-test confirmed that effluent turbidity from both plants was significantly below the 5 NTU threshold. Turbidity removal efficiency can be calculated using two methods: (1) the mean of daily efficiencies which is the average of daily efficiencies, and (2) the efficiency based on average influent and effluent turbidity values. This study recommends the second method for evaluating conventional WTPs. Additionally, disinfection was successful in both plants, with average daily free chlorine concentrations of 1.41 mg/L for Dokan-1 and 2.26 mg/L for Dokan-2.

References

Ali, H., Zageer, D. & Alwash, A. 2019. Performance evaluation of drinking water treatment plant in Iraq. Oriental Journal of Physical Sciences, 4, 18-29.

Ali, S., Ali, A., Hussain, S. A., Hussain, K., Begum, F., Akbar, M., Raza, G., Ali, K. & Hyder, S. 2015. Functional status and water quality analysis of fifty-six water purification plants established at Gilgit District, Pakistan. Journal of Biodiversity and Environmental Sciences (JBES) 6 (4), 332, 340.

Alver, A. 2019. Evaluation of conventional drinking water treatment plant efficiency according to water quality index and health risk assessment. Environmental Science and Pollution Research, 26, 27225-27238.

Ayu, M., Hadisoebroto, R. & Ratnaningsih, R. Treatment of performance evaluation at Cisauk water treatment plant, Cisauk Sub-district, Tangerang. Journal of Physics: Conference Series, 2019. IOP Publishing, 022098.

Aziz, S. Q. & Omar, I. A. 2019. Performance Evaluation and Water Quality Index Analysis for Qandil Water Treatment Plant. Polytechnic Journal, 12, 4.

Bwapwa, J. K., Mkhize, N. & Seyam, M. 2024. Evaluation of operational efficiency and performance for a water treatment plant. South African Journal of Chemical Engineering, 49, 11-34.

Choudhury, S. & Saha, A. K. 2018. Prediction of operation efficiency of water treatment plant with the help of multi-criteria decision-making. Water Conservation Science and Engineering, 3, 79-90.

Davis, M. L. 2010. Water and wastewater engineering: design principles and practice, McGraw-Hill.

Hamaamin, Y. A. & Abdullah, J. B. 2020. Temporal Variation of Drinking Water Quality Parameters for Sulaimani City, Kurdistan Region, Iraq. UHD Journal of Science and Technology, 4, 99-106.

Hassan, J. N. 2017. Performance Evaluation of Dohuk Water Treatment Plant. Journal of Duhok University, 207-219.

Helsel, D. R., Hirsch, R. M., Ryberg, K. R., Archfield, S. A. & Gilroy, E. J. 2020. Statistical methods in water resources. Techniques and Methods. Reston, VA.

Ibrahim, A., Onyenekwe, P. & Nwaedozie, I. 2014. An efficiency assessment of Lower Usuma water treatment plant in Abuja Metropolis, Nigeria. IOSR Journal of Environmental Science, Toxicology and Food Technology, 8, 46-53.

Janna, H. & Al-Samawi, A. 2014. Performance Evaluation of Al-Karkh Water Treatment Plant in the City of Baghdad. International Journal of Advanced Research, 2, 823-829.

Katila, P., Pierce Colfer, C. J., De Jong, W., Galloway, G., Pacheco, P. & Winkel, G. 2019. Sustainable Development Goals: Their Impacts on Forests and People, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.

Khan, A. A. & Ahmad, S. K. 2018. Performance evaluation of water treatment plant at Nangloi, New Delhi: A Case Study. International Journal of Research in Engineering and Technology, 7, 49-60.

Khan, S., Guan, Y., Khan, F. & Khan, Z. 2020. A comprehensive index for measuring water security in an urbanizing world: the case of Pakistan’s capital. Water, 12, 166.

Mendez-Ruiz, J. I., Barcia-Carreño, M. B., Mejía-Bustamante, L. J., Cornejo-Pozo, Á. K., Salas-Vázquez, C. A. & Valverde-Armas, P. E. 2023. Assessment of the performance of a water treatment plant in Ecuador: hydraulic resizing of the treatment units. Sustainability, 15, 1235.

Mesfun, N. M. & Derib, S. D. 2024. Performance Evaluation and Factors Influencing a Drinking Water Treatment Plant, Shire Indassilassie, Ethiopia. Water-Energy Nexus.

Mohammad, T. A., Hamza, J. N. & Ameen, A. M. S. 2023. The Effects of Intake Water Quality and Filtration Unit Performance on the Efficiency of the Al-Rasheed Water Treatment Plant in Baghdad, Iraq. Iraqi Journal of Science, 6158-6174.

Nasier, M. & Abdulrazzaq, K. A. 2022. Performance evaluation the turbidity removal efficiency of AL-Muthana water treatment plant. Journal of Engineering, 28, 1-13.

Nawaz, S. & Ali, Y. 2018. Factors Affecting the Performance of Water Treatment Plants in Pakistan. Water Conservation Science and Engineering, 3, 191-203.

Omar, I. A. & Aziz, S. Q. 2021. Research on Performance Evaluation and Improvement of Ifraz-2 Water Treatment Plant. Recent Res. Adv. Biol, 7, 9-22.

Ott, R. & Longnecker, M. 2016. An introduction to statistical methods and data analysis, Cengage Learning.

Rasooly, S. S. & Anwer, M. 2023. Assessment of Drinking Water Quality and the Efficiency of the Two Water Treatment Plants in UP, India. Journal of Mechanical, Civil and Industrial Engineering, 4, 01-08.

Rice, E. W., Baird, R. B., Eaton, A. D. & Clesceri, L. S. 2017. Standard methods for the examination of water and wastewater.

Setty, K. E., Enault, J., Loret, J.-F., Puigdomenech Serra, C., Martin-Alonso, J. & Bartram, J. 2018. Time series study of weather, water quality, and acute gastroenteritis at Water Safety Plan implementation sites in France and Spain. International Journal of Hygiene and Environmental Health, 221, 714-726.

Sudhakaran, S., Lattemann, S. & Amy, G. L. 2013. Appropriate drinking water treatment processes for organic micropollutants removal based on experimental and model studies - a multi-criteria analysis study. Sci Total Environ, 442, 478-88.

Sulaymaniyah Water Directorate. 2013. Drinking Water Quality Report in Sulaymaniyah Governorate (Seasonal Report 1) Sulaymaniyah Water Directorate- Sulaymaniyah-Iraq

Von Sperling, M., Verbyla, M. E. & Oliveira, S. M. 2020. Assessment of treatment plant performance and water quality data: a guide for students, researchers and practitioners, IWA publishing.

WHO. 2022. Guidelines for drinking-water quality: incorporating the first and second addenda, World Health Organization.